Feast of the Seven Fishes: A Christmas Eve Dinner in Six Bottles
Christmas Eve in Italian-American homes means La Vigilia, the Feast of the Seven Fishes: a long, joyful seafood dinner that every family makes its own way. Some start with fried calamari and baccalà, others with raw oysters and clams, and the night might end with a rich zuppa di pesce. So alongside a Sicilian white, we went to the great seafood wines of France and Portugal's Atlantic coast: a grower Champagne to open, two saline whites for the raw bar and the fry, and three lighter reds that play beautifully with fish.
Champagne Sourdet-Diot, "Cuvée Prestige" Brut, Vallée de la Marne
The Opening Toast
Sourdet-Diot is a family-owned grower estate in La Caure, in the southern reaches of the Vallée de la Marne, farming its own vines plot by plot rather than buying fruit like the big houses. "Cuvée Prestige" is the top of their range: 45% Chardonnay for finesse, with Meunier and Pinot Noir adding depth, plus a generous share of reserve wines and three to four years on the lees. Expect baked yellow apple, white peach and lemon curd layered with toasted brioche and roasted nuts, all carried on a fine, creamy mousse and a crisp, chalky finish.
Pair with: Fried calamari, baccalà fritters, fried smelts, and anything golden and crispy.
Morgado de Bucelas, "Puro Calcárico" Arinto, Bucelas DOC, Portugal
The Atlantic Raw-Bar White
Just north of Lisbon, the tiny Bucelas region has been prized for its whites since Roman times. "Puro Calcárico" means "pure limestone," a nod to the fossil-rich soils of Quinta do Boição's highest hillside plots, where cool Atlantic fog keeps the Arinto grape's acidity electric. Made entirely in stainless steel and aged on its lees, it's linear and chiseled, with green apple, lime blossom, grapefruit pith, crushed oyster shell, and a sea-spray salinity that leaves your palate clean and ready for the next bite.
Pair with: Oysters on the half shell, clams casino, grilled sardines, and salt cod in any form.
Il Censo, "Praruar" Terre Siciliane Bianco, Sicily
The Sicilian Wild Card
Il Censo is a 200-year-old farmstead in the high, remote interior of Sicily, where proprietor Gaetano Gargano works hand in hand with legendary Umbrian vigneron Giampiero Bea of Paolo Bea fame. "Praruar" (prah-roo-AHR) is 100% Catarratto, Sicily's native white grape, from organically farmed vines, fermented with wild yeasts and left on its skins for two to three weeks, with no fining or filtration. That skin contact gives it an amber-gold glow and gentle grip, but it stays bright and refreshing: dried apricot, orange blossom and wild herbs, with citrus, sea-air salinity and a snappy almond-skin finish.
Pair with: Grilled swordfish with lemon and herbs, baccalà, fritto misto, and garlicky shellfish pastas.
Grégoire Hoppenot, Fleurie "Origines," Cru Beaujolais
The Red That Loves Seafood
Grégoire Hoppenot has become one of the most celebrated names in modern Beaujolais, and "Origines" is his flagship Fleurie. Organic Gamay grown on pink granite is fermented with whole clusters and native yeasts, then aged in neutral oak, so nothing gets in the way of the fruit. Wild strawberry, crushed violets and black tea meet silky, fine-grained tannins and lively acidity. Give it a light chill and it's as at home next to fish as any white.
Pair with: Seared salmon, roasted cod, tuna, and mussels in a light tomato broth. Serve slightly chilled.
Domaine Dozon, Chinon "Le Saut au Loup," Loire Valley
The Herb-Garden Cabernet Franc
In 2013, Éric Santier, trained alongside François Chidaine, took over this historic Chinon estate and moved it to organic farming. "Le Saut au Loup" is the domaine's crown jewel, a south-facing monopole vineyard on flinty clay over tuffeau limestone. Native-yeast fermentation in concrete and aging in neutral oak deliver dark raspberry, wild blackberry, violets and a classic touch of bay leaf, with fine, chalky tannins and bright limestone freshness.
Pair with: Grilled swordfish, herb-roasted fish, stuffed calamari, and shrimp fra diavolo.
António Bernardino Paulo da Silva, "Casal da Azenha" Tinto, Lisboa, Portugal
The Seaside Old-Timer
António Bernardino Paulo da Silva is the master of Colares, one of the last guardians of the ancient coastal winemaking on Portugal's Atlantic edge. "Casal da Azenha" comes from the hillside zone bordering Colares, where clay and limestone meet cooling ocean winds. Fermented in old open-top cement lagares and aged for years in large neutral vats, this Castelão-led blend shows dried red currant, sour cherry, pine and a distinct hint of sea salt, with rustic, food-friendly tannins. It even comes finished with a real cork label.
Pair with: Zuppa di pesce, cioppino, baccalà stewed with tomatoes, and the heartiest dishes at the end of the night.