Perhaps some of you remember this massive, decades-old lineup of verticals that Drake Whitcraft, Master Sommelier Brian McClintic, and myself had the pleasure of tasting two years ago. Well, had today’s 2018 Pence Ranch “Clone 115” been a part of that lineup at the time, it would’ve been vying for first place on the podium. It’s wines sculpted exactly like this that represent the very best of elegant, authentically old-school Pinot Noir. These wines always have something profound to say, without ever raising their voice, which is why they slip right into elite, around-the-world Pinot Noir tastings with ease.
Having learned the craft from his tradition-minded father, as well as the legend Burt Williams of Williams Selyem—perhaps the most historically important name in domestic Pinot Noir—Drake Whitcraft’s creations have become especially beloved throughout sommelier circles and earned him a top spot among California’s trendiest producers. So what’s the secret to becoming a Pinot Noir superstar? You seek out great vineyard sites (Pence Ranch), planted to the best Dijon clones (115), and from them craft organic, nonintervention wines with marked terroir character (today’s offer). No matter how you look at it, this 2018 bottling from Whitcraft is world-class wine, on par with some of my current favorites from Burgundy. Given its extremely limited production—only 88 cases were produced and 15 remain—we are only able to offer up to six bottles per person. If you collect wine in any capacity, you must own Whitcraft.
Chris Whitcraft founded his eponymous winery in 1985 under the guidance of the minds behind American icons like Heitz, Williams Selyem, and Chalone. His son, Drake, officially came aboard in 2000 and eventually took over the winemaking in 2007. He took what his father taught him and further honed his skills under the watchful eye of the one-and-only Burt Williams (whose track record speaks for itself). Drake sources from a multitude of special single vineyards, crafting breathtaking wines that have been left to their own devices. And believe me when I say they are quickly gobbled up by wine purists.
Today’s wine hails from a small
4.29-acre block (scroll down and look for ‘4E’ in the photo) within the “Pence Ranch” vineyard, a limestone and clay outcrop in the eastern reaches of Santa Rita Hills. Drake farms organically and practices many biodynamic principles at his winery—just like his father, Drake is a staunch believer in creating wine without manipulation. Without any assistance from electricity, all grapes are hand-harvested and a whole-cluster fermentation (there is no de-stemmer at the winery) occurs over a 10-day period. The free-run juice is transferred into neutral oak barrels, where it ages without being racked from its lees. It is bottled via gravity in-house without fining or filtering so that every ounce of purity and aromatic complexity intact.
Not only is this a youthful wine, it’s made in an almost entirely natural manner‚ what Drake calls “real winemaking.” Because it’s unracked, unfiltered, unfined, un-everything (except for the slightest bit of sulfur), I always recommend decanting his younger wines carefully and allowing them to soak up oxygen before pouring into your largest Burgundy stems. I’m guessing a great deal of you haven’t experienced 100% whole-cluster Pinot Noir before—not many producers can pull it off so skillfully. DRC and Dujac do it flawlessly in Burgundy, but only the top 1% can afford those prices. I’ll tell you what—Whitcraft is a solid, affordable trade-off. After air, the wine slowly unfurls with supple forest fruit and savory elegance in the aromatic form of pulverized earth, damp moss, rose stem, pomegranate oil, subtle spices, citrus peel, wild sage, and black tea. The palate is filled with delicate notes of brambleberry, spiced plum, licorice, and black cherry but it’s all about the crushed mineral savor and earthy underbrush. If I weren’t so familiar with these wines, I feel like one would almost be forced to call blue-chip Burgundy from a prestigious producer. It’s just that savory, earthy, and nuanced; such a beautiful creation. Enjoy now with a minimum one-hour decant and over the next 7-10 years. Cheers.