By now you’ve probably formed a whole set of expectations as to what a $20-ish bottle of California Chardonnay is going to be like. Well, if you were thinking along the lines of ‘soft, tropical, sweet(ish), and buttery,’ think again: One of California’s true Chardonnay whisperers has, in our view, shifted the paradigm.
Many of you are likely familiar with twin brothers Bob and Jim Varner, who have been fixtures of the Santa Cruz Mountain wine scene for decades; their taut, elegant, cool-climate Chardonnays and Pinot Noirs are benchmarks for any wine list purporting to showcase the best of California, and it’s a testament to the low-key humility of the brothers that their wines never became stratospherically priced. This wine is from a relatively new frontier for the Varners—Santa Barbara County—and what it delivers at its incredibly modest price is downright shocking. We sat down with Bob Varner recently to learn more about Varner’s Santa Barbara project, and the 2014s (we’ll be offering the Pinot Noir soon) herald an exciting new chapter for a great winemaking family. The tension, purity, and refinement of these wines, at this price, is truly exceptional. Do yourself a favor and grab some!
As we were surprised to learn during our visit, the Varners—who’d been farming the same sites in the Santa Cruz Mountains since 1980—didn’t own their Santa Cruz vineyards. After parting ways with their longtime lessor there (2014 was their last Santa Cruz vintage), they’ve launched a few new projects—Foxglove is a value-oriented brand that includes two reds (a Cabernet and a Zinfandel) from Paso Robles, and the Varner name now graces a pair of wines from the Los Alamos region of Santa Barbara County. Although it isn’t an officially recognized AVA (the wines carry the ‘Santa Barbara County’ appellation), Los Alamos is sandwiched between the Santa Maria and Santa Ynez Valleys, with the same kind of east-west orientation that allows cool Pacific air to be funneled inland—creating dramatic diurnal temperature swings that help slow growth and preserve acidity in grapes. The “El Camino” vineyard, source of this Chardonnay, is a few miles inland from the famed Los Alamos vineyard (source of the Varner Pinot, among others, including a bottling from Au Bon Climat); it has a northwesterly aspect and sandy loam soils, and is farmed organically.
Varner’s 2014 from the El Camino site (only their second vintage of the wine) was fermented in stainless steel and did not go through malolactic fermentation, which is one reason the wine has such electrifying acidity. It was aged mostly in stainless steel on its lees, with a portion (about 25%) aged in large French oak puncheons. It shows terrific freshness, and doesn’t skew ‘tropical,’ as many Santa Barbara County Chardonnays do. The combination of crispness, minerality and depth of fruit had us thinking of upper-tier wines from Burgundy’s Mâcon, and not in the least about some of the oaky/buttery stereotypes (pretty outdated, really) that still dog California Chardonnay.
In the glass the 2014 El Camino Vineyard Chardonnay is a medium yellow-gold extending to the rim, with a refreshing blast of yellow apple, Bartlett pear, salted lemon, white flowers and a touch of wildflower honey leaping from the glass. It isn’t as mineral as, say, a Chablis, but it is built to a similar scale, with refreshing acidity and a hint of creaminess. The wine has amazing purity, texture, and grip at a price that typically gets you a glass of fruit cocktail. What a find! Serve it at 45 degrees in all-purpose white stems and pair it with some Pacific seafood—it would be dynamite with some lemon-drizzled fried or grilled oysters, in fact. Check it out with the attached recipe and prepare to re-calibrate your California Chardonnay palate (if any re-calibration is necessary). This stuff changes the game. Cheers!