In a mega-famous region where words like “big,” “expensive,” and “flashy” are commonly thrown around, there’s nothing more refreshing than unearthing Teaderman’s perfectly preserved library releases. They hardly make any wine, but what they do emerge with is a master class on extremely long-aged, exquisitely crafted, elegance-over-extraction Oakville Cabernet. For decades, this small team has diligently farmed their slice of vines (where an acre can fetch hundreds of thousands of dollars) right in the midst of Napa Valley's cultiest labels.
And still, theirs remains an affordable farm-to-table Cab, one that takes a painfully long time to actually hit your table. Not many wineries have the ability to re-release a 15-year-old wine and virtually nobody can do it when factoring in today’s drop-in-the-ocean production, so while finding a flawless ‘04 may be an extraordinary feat for most, that’s just the gold standard at Teaderman (their current Cabernet release is 2008!). Clearly, one of their priorities from the beginning was to hold a substantial percentage of each vintage in reserve for future release, and today’s offer, culled directly from ideal storage conditions in their “library,” is a testament to their patience and confidence. If you enjoy classic, 100% Cabernet from one of the world’s most illustrious areas, this is about as brilliant as it gets.
The Teaderman family has never made a lot of wine, so you may not have heard of their eponymous label, but they’re hardly newcomers to this storied terroir: Stan and Patty Teaderman bought their 14-acre vineyard in 1978, and for years sold Sauvignon Blanc to Robert Mondavi for his famous ‘Fumé Blanc’ bottling. As time passed, they planted more and more Cabernet Sauvignon—as any sane grower in Oakville would—and began making small amounts of wine to share with friends and family. Then came an actual label, in 2001, with the first commercial wines crafted by Silver Oak legend (and neighbor) Justin Meyer.
To pinpoint its location more precisely, the 14-acre Teaderman vineyard is on Oakville Cross Road, directly across from Groth Vineyards (another Justin Meyer project back in the day). The Teadermans describe it as having the classical clay/loam soil structure of the Oakville valley floor, but with a streak of the alluvial gravel typically found a little higher up the slope. Before they ever thought about making a bottle of wine, the Teadermans were ‘growers’ first, and I think this mentality is reflected in the style of their wines: Tasting this ‘04 means tasting not just pure, ripe, dark-toned fruit but a savory, smoky soil component as well. Particularly now with some time in bottle, the primary fruit intensity of youth has given way to a more complex, earth-driven flavor profile.
Only 15%-20% of the vineyard’s production is reserved for Teaderman-labeled wines, which include just this Cabernet, a Sauvignon Blanc, and a reserve Cabernet Sauvignon, which they started making in 2012. The wines are vinified at a nearby custom crush facility, with production these days overseen by Stan Teaderman’s grandson, Dustin Kaiser, and winemaker Anne Vawter. All the fruit is handpicked and de-stemmed before fermentation in stainless steel vessels. It is then transferred into 100% new French oak where heaps of undisturbed aging occurs, about 24 months. It was bottled in 2007 with minimal filtration and this batch sat motionlessly for well over a dozen years. Thus, today’s library release was born.
Because it saw two years of deep rest in oak, has a hardy core of 100% Cabernet, and remained untouched in a dark, cool place for 12 years, many of you may have a hard time nailing the vintage of Teaderman’s 2004. At 15 years old, this reveals a deep, brooding core of dark ruby and, after about 30 minutes in a decanter, explodes with a dazzling array of highly perfumed crème de cassis, black raspberry, plum skin, and Morello cherry before a surge of tobacco leaf, crushed graphite, violets, green herbs, dusty earth, baking spice, sandalwood, and leather sound off. It impressively balances a full-bodied palate with finesse and focus, bringing in lifted notes of freshness that accentuate the layers of dark fruit and pulverized valley floor minerality at play. It’s always fascinating to taste a wine with this much bottle age and wager how much longer it has—based on the core of fruit and underlying structure on display, this will coast into 2030 if you stash a few bottles in your cellar. But make no mistake, Teaderman’s pitch-perfect expression of mature Napa Cabernet has entered its prime and is ready to enjoy, especially alongside a herb-crusted standing rib roast. Cheers!