For many people in the wine business, at some point it’s not enough to serve and/or sell wine—the desire to make some becomes too great to ignore. We’ve featured many sellers-turned-makers here at SommSelect (Greg Harrington of Gramercy Cellars in Washington; Erin Nuccio of Evesham Wood/Haden Fig in Oregon; Raj Parr of Domaine de la Côte in California), and today we add British expat Tim Telli to the list.
Telli is a talented “urban winemaker” sourcing premium grapes from around California and turning them into wine in San Francisco’s Mission District, where he also lives with his family. His Betwixt label is a recent, and very exciting, discovery for us—this Anderson Valley Pinot Noir from the “Helluva Vineyard” in Boonville is a beautiful evocation of its place of origin and an extremely well-priced one at that. Telli produced just 85 cases of this critically acclaimed 2015, showing some pretty precocious talent for someone who not too long ago was working in wine retail and fantasizing about one day having his name on a bottle. And let me assure you that while Tim may be a nice guy with an inspiring story, we wouldn’t be offering this wine if it wasn’t great. This balanced, perfumed, cool-climate Pinot Noir has a quality-to-price ratio as high as any domestic Pinot Noir we’ve featured all year. We were offered a small chunk of his tiny production to share with our subscribers, and if this 2015 is any indication, I suspect you’ll be hearing more about Tim Telli here and elsewhere.
If you left San Francisco and drove north on 101 until you hit Route 128, you’d hit Anderson Valley in about three hours. It’s a land of rolling hills and coastal fog in still-rural Mendocino County, with a more rustic, less-traveled feel in comparison to the Napa and Sonoma Valleys. The Helluva Vineyard is a 10-acre site in Boonville (where some older residents still speak a local dialect called Boontling, a mix of English, Gaelic, and Spanish spawned in the 1800s) that has supplied fruit to many noteworthy wineries, including Handley and Smith-Story. Telli was first offered fruit from the site in 2014, and was thrilled to get the chance to work with it again in 2015—a drought-stressed year that delivered concentrated fruit which, thanks to Anderson Valley’s cooler temperatures, managed to retain its acidity and freshness.
Of the many things that impressed me about this wine—its energy, its aromatics, its value-for-dollar—perhaps what impressed me most is that Telli only started making wine a few years ago. Originally from West Sussex, England, he had been feeling the pull of wine even before moving out to California, but said it was “all over” once he got a job in wine retail. After learning all he could about the bottles in the shop, he started taking weeks off for wine harvests, then interned at local wineries. After he fell headlong into the winemaking rabbit hole, he honed his skills at AP Vin, August West, and ROAR before leaving to make his first wines in 2012—a half-ton of Grenache, and a Marsanne/Roussane white blend that Robert Parker gave 92 points. This 2015 is, as noted above, just his second vintage working with Helluva Vineyard; the wine was fermented using only native yeasts and was aged 15 months in French oak barrels, of which only 28% were new.
In the glass, the 2015 Betwixt “Helluva Vineyard” Pinot Noir is a bright, reflective ruby-red with garnet and pink highlights at the rim. Where many Anderson Valley Pinots can be bright and red-fruited but also a little wan, this one has a firm tannic structure and great acidity lending it backbone and drive. The nose is packed with notes of wild strawberry, rhubarb, dried orange peel, goji berry, rose petal, crushed earth, a touch of mushroom powder, and has an accent of exotic spices. It is medium-bodied, with a beautiful core of sweetness that moves to a savory and beautifully fresh finish. Its push-pull of sweet/savory had me thinking of some of the greats from further north in Oregon, and while it is drinking beautifully now, it has the potential to age 5-10 years if kept well. Ideally, pull the cork one hour before serving at cellar temp in large Burgundy stems. Its energy and mineral savor will lend it great versatility with food—I feel, as I often do with Pinot Noir, that you could throw a dart at a list of recipes and get a great pairing. Check out the attached recipe as we transition into fall; this wine will help make it a smooth one. Enjoy!